RateMyJob

At RateMyJob, we believe work shouldn’t be a chore, but when it is, you should at least get a good story out of it. So we’ve scoured the web for the funniest and most outrageous stories from professionals from all industries, to bring you a little humor and entertainment when you need it most.

  • Career
  • Humor
  • Culture
  • Leadership
  • Perks

Big Data To The Rescue: Police Use Fitbit To Charge 90-Year-Old Man With Murdering His Stepdaughter

By Adam Patton
October 10, 2018

Flickr / zziuni

A California man is looking at jail time after being found guilty of brutally murdering his stepdaughter in her home last month. When authorities went to carry out a welfare check on Karen Navarra, 67, they found her dead with her throat slit, a massive cut on her head, and a kitchen knife in her hand according to the San Jose Police Department. All signs pointed to suicide, but when the medical examiner noticed that she’d also sustained several skull fractures, it was decided that her injuries were “were inconsistent with being self-inflicted or accidental.”

“Based on the totality of the circumstances and information received, detectives believed the homicide of victim Karen Navarra was staged to appear as though it was a suicide,” stated Brian Meeker, a San Jose police detective.

Pixabay / StockSnap

When police spoke with Navarra’s mother and stepfather and both seemed distraught and deeply saddened by the notion that their daughter felt compelled to take her own life. But the more authorities questioned Anthony Aiello, Navarra’s 90-year-old stepfather, the more things didn’t add up.

He claimed that the last time he saw his stepdaughter was on September 8 when he had dropped off some homemade pizza and biscotti at her house around 3 o’clock in the afternoon. He said that he stayed and chatted with her for about 15 minutes before departing, and that they only other time he saw her that day was when he spotted her driving by his house. But when police obtained video footage from a security camera near Navarro’s home, it never showed Navarra driving by.

Luckily for authorities, there was a silent bystander present during the murder who was able to provide some pretty condemning evidence about who the actual killer was. In fact, the bystander was so close to the crime that it was touching Navarra when she passed.

San Jose police used data from a Fitbit device in the case against a 90-year-old man who is accused of murdering his stepdaughter and staging her death to look like a suicide. https://t.co/0bk9LWbVts pic.twitter.com/MIpyYUyu2J

— USA TODAY Video (@usatodayvideo) October 4, 2018

After Aiello’s inconsistent alibi gave police reason to be suspicious, they applied to get a search warrant for Navarra’s FitBit Alta HR so that they could access information about her heart rate and movement. It turned out that the Fitbit stopped registering any heart rate data exactly at 3:28 pm. Video footage obtained by police showed that Aiello’s car was parked in the driveway of Navarra’s home from 3:12 pm until 3:33 pm. His story was seeming less and less credible, so he was arrested and taken to the department’s homicide unit for further questioning.

As Aiello was being held, other detectives searched his home where they found some of his clothes with reddish brown statins that tested “presumptive positive” for blood. When the officers at the station confronted him about the Fitbit data which indicated that Navarra had died before he left the house, Aiello continued to deny that he was present during her death and proposed that there was someone else in the house. When asked about the bloodstains found on his clothes, he claimed that he is clumsy and accidentally cuts himself frequently. “He was told that the deposits of blood were not localized in one area and were more consistent with splatter. Aiello indicated that he might have cut his hand and shaken it while he was wearing those shirts,” a detective wrote in the affidavit.

When detectives left the room, they could hear Aiello talking to himself and getting upset. “Among other things, he repeated the statement, ‘I’m done,’ a number of times,” said Detective Meeker. He was then held in the Santa Clara County Jail until his court hearing at the end of September, where he was formally charged with personal use of a deadly weapon. The length of his sentence has not been determined.

https://twitter.com/DC_CyberProtect/status/1049583316561727488

In addition to being a high tech way to monitor one’s health, Fitbits are seeing more and more use by law enforcement as a means to access physical data that is relevant to solving a crime.

Fitbit location data played a major role in a sexual assault case in Pennsylvania in 2015 and a personal injury case in Canada in 2014. A Garmin Vivosmart GPS recorded a woman’s struggle with an attacker in Seattle in 2017. That same year, authorities used data from the Fitbit of a Connecticut woman to charge her husband with murder. This year F.B.I. experts sifted through data from the Fitbit of Mollie Tibbetts, a 20-year-old student at the center of a high profile manhunt that lasted until her body was discovered in August. All of this proves that while some uses of ‘Big Data’ can seem creepy and invasive, certain data can also end up being valuable sources of information when authorities are trying to pin down a perpetrator.

What do you think about this case? Do you have any theories about Aiello’s motive for murdering his stepdaughter? Are there any pieces of technology/data sources that should be off limits when police are investigating a crime? Let us know in the comments down below!

    Primary Sidebar

    Most Popular

    CareerRestaurant Employees Dish On The One Customer Everyone Dreaded Serving
    Zach Brown
    HumorThese Are The Funniest Restaurant Names We Could Find
    Zach Brown
    CareerGolf Course Beverage Cart Drivers Share What Their Job Is Really Like
    Brooklyn Bubz

    Editor's Picks

    Humor26 Steak-umm Tweets That Prove It Is The Most Delightfully Peculiar Brand On Twitter
    Will Jamison Eucker
    Humor22 Of The Most Savage Brand Tweets Ever Tweeted
    Will Jamison Eucker

    Trending

    HumorThe 17 Most Accurate Karen Memes For Anyone Who Has Dealt With A Karen At Work
    Will Jamison Eucker
    Humor20 Of The Most Peculiar Walmart Customers To Ever Exist
    Will Jamison Eucker

    Secondary Sidebar

    Can't Miss Stories

    HumorThe 16 Funniest Signs Come From This One Restaurant
    Will Jamison Eucker
    CareerPeople Share The Most Condescending Thing Someone Told Them At Work
    Christina Raines
    HumorThe 5 Worst Karen Meltdowns The Manager Could Not Handle
    Will Jamison Eucker

    Must Reads

    HumorThe 6 Most Dramatic Ways That People Quit Their Jobs
    Will Jamison Eucker
    CareerKaren Bullies Her Coworker, Until She Gets Caught Lying About Her Disability
    Christina Raines

    Popular Picks

    Humor14 Times Employees Called Out Their Weird Bosses On The Internet
    Will Jamison Eucker
    Humor5 Most Satisfying Times Workers Saw “Justice Served” On Entitled Customers
    Brooklyn Bubz

    What People Really Think About Their Jobs
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use