RateMyJob

At RateMyJob, we believe work shouldn’t be a chore, but when it is, you should at least get a good story out of it. So we’ve scoured the web for the funniest and most outrageous stories from professionals from all industries, to bring you a little humor and entertainment when you need it most.

  • Career
  • Humor
  • Culture
  • Leadership
  • Perks

Deaf Costco Employee Fired For Being ‘Too Loud’ Receives Massive Compensation

By Adam Patton
April 9, 2019

Flickr / JeepersMedia

When Miami-native Christine D’Onofrio found out she’d won her suit against wholesale giant Costco, filed on account of discrimination against her due to her hearing impairment, she was mostly just relieved that the company was found guilty of breaking the law, according to her attorney Chad Levy. The amount she was awarded in damages? $775,000.

“Honestly, this was never about money for her,” Levy said. “She is very smart with an incredible memory, but her disability limits her ceiling. Stocking at Costco was the best and highest-paying job she would attain. It took her 24 years to reach the $20.30 hourly rate.”

Deaf ex-employee wins $775,000 in discrimination case against Pompano Beach Costco https://t.co/qQVlbh4ScA pic.twitter.com/0OULqOT1JD

— South Florida Sun Sentinel (@SunSentinel) July 10, 2018

According to D’Onofrio’s lawsuit, she was fired in October of 2013, but her conflicts with management started long before that. She had spent a full year prior to her termination begging for Costco to take her disability more seriously, requesting a translator so that she could better communicate with her coworkers, which they denied. Management also denied her proposition that they merely write down their communications with pen and paper, and instead gave her a video phone, which “worked great at meetings, but served little purpose during regular work.”

According to the University of Rochester School of Medicine, “The United States funds a service called ‘Video Relay Services’ (VRS) to provide interpreters to Deaf people to make telephone calls. The video phone, often called a VP, can be used to talk to others via a sign language interpreter, who connects with a person who can hear through a regular phone.”

Soon after D’Onofrio began using her video phone, management reprimanded her for causing disturbances in the store by yelling into the device, even though her disability prevents her from controlling the volume of her voice at times. She was written up for the loudness issue, which prompted her to pen a letter to Costco CEO Walter Craig Jelinek in which she reported her unfair treatment. Soon after she sent her letter, she was suspended for a week. Eight days after that, she was fired.

Wikimedia Commons

D’Onofrio immediately filed a lawsuit under the Florida Civil Rights Act of 1992, citing actions by her managers that she deemed “intentional, willful, malicious and with gross disregard for [her] rights.” Costco vehemently denied her claims, saying that it was absolutely untrue that she “never had any performance problems, and was never warned, counseled or disciplined at any time during her tenure.”

Costco also asserted that D’Onofrio had been disciplined many times during her time with the company for “serious misconduct and insubordination.” Their attorneys also maintained that the actions of D’Onofrio’s managers were completely unrelated to the company as a whole, saying, “If it occurred, it was outside the scope of that individual’s employment, was not authorized or condoned by the Defendant (the company), and was undertaken without the knowledge or consent of Defendant. Thus, the Defendant is not liable for any such conduct, if it occurred.”

"I have been employed with Costco for 23 years and have never been treated with such disrespect and discrimination due to my disability." #Deaf https://t.co/mL9jeTDaIG

— Miami New Times (@miaminewtimes) July 2, 2018

However, the jury completely disagreed with Costco’s claims, citing one especially damaging piece of evidence which indicated that D’Onofrio’s direct supervisor did not receive disability sensitivity training because she missed the meeting. Had she been present, she would have learned that when deaf people yell, it’s often unrelated to any anger or emotion duress.

According to D’Onofrio’s lawyer, Chad Levy, “It became apparent through the trial that Costco really was focused on protecting the company’s interest as opposed to Christine’s. The size of the award and the punitive damages demonstrates that the jury believed this was not an accident.” D’Onofrio was awarded “$750,000 for emotional pain and mental anguish caused by the denial of reasonable accommodations after Dec. 9, 2012, and $25,000 as punitive damages for Costco’s failure to provide reasonable accommodations.”

What do you think about this case? Was there any truth in Costco’s argument, or is it just another case of corporate greed? What will D’Onofrio’s do next? Let us know in the comments down below!

    Primary Sidebar

    Most Popular

    CareerRestaurant Employees Dish On The One Customer Everyone Dreaded Serving
    Zach Brown
    HumorThese Are The Funniest Restaurant Names We Could Find
    Zach Brown
    CareerGolf Course Beverage Cart Drivers Share What Their Job Is Really Like
    Brooklyn Bubz

    Editor's Picks

    Humor26 Steak-umm Tweets That Prove It Is The Most Delightfully Peculiar Brand On Twitter
    Will Jamison Eucker
    Humor22 Of The Most Savage Brand Tweets Ever Tweeted
    Will Jamison Eucker

    Trending

    HumorThe 17 Most Accurate Karen Memes For Anyone Who Has Dealt With A Karen At Work
    Will Jamison Eucker
    Humor20 Of The Most Peculiar Walmart Customers To Ever Exist
    Will Jamison Eucker

    Secondary Sidebar

    Can't Miss Stories

    HumorThe 16 Funniest Signs Come From This One Restaurant
    Will Jamison Eucker
    CareerPeople Share The Most Condescending Thing Someone Told Them At Work
    Christina Raines
    HumorThe 5 Worst Karen Meltdowns The Manager Could Not Handle
    Will Jamison Eucker

    Must Reads

    HumorThe 6 Most Dramatic Ways That People Quit Their Jobs
    Will Jamison Eucker
    CareerKaren Bullies Her Coworker, Until She Gets Caught Lying About Her Disability
    Christina Raines

    Popular Picks

    Humor14 Times Employees Called Out Their Weird Bosses On The Internet
    Will Jamison Eucker
    Humor5 Most Satisfying Times Workers Saw “Justice Served” On Entitled Customers
    Brooklyn Bubz

    What People Really Think About Their Jobs
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use